Israel's First King

The King Who Forgot to Listen: A Lesson in Obedience from the Story of Saul 

Have you ever asked your child to clean their room, only to find them shoving everything under the bed with a sigh? They did what you asked, but not really. The room isn't truly clean, and their heart certainly wasn't in it. As parents, we know there's a huge difference between begrudgingly following a rule and obeying with a good and willing heart. 

The biblical story of King Saul is one of the most powerful and cautionary tales about this very lesson. It's not just a story for adults; it's a profound example for our kids about what God truly values. This post will break down Saul's story and provide practical ways for you to discuss the vital lesson that "to obey is better than sacrifice" with your children. 

  -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 

  1. The People Ask for a King (And Why It Mattered) 

Before Saul, Israel was led by judges, like the prophet Samuel. But when Samuel grew old, his sons did not follow his example; they were corrupt, took bribes, and perverted justice (1 Samuel 8:3). The elders of Israel saw this and came to Samuel with a demand. 

They said, "Now appoint a king for us to judge us like all the nations" (1 Samuel 8:5). They wanted a king to lead them in battle and give them a sense of security, just like the countries around them. 

This request may sound reasonable, but it revealed a deeper heart issue. A judge was God's temporary deliverer, called up for a specific purpose, which required the people to continually depend on God. A king, however, was a permanent human ruler to whom they could switch their loyalty and allegiance. This is why God explained to Samuel that the people's demand was not a rejection of Samuel's leadership, but a rejection of God as their true king (1 Samuel 8:7). 

Despite God's warning that an earthly king would take their sons for his army, their daughters for his service, and the best of their fields and servants (1 Samuel 8:11-18), the people insisted. God granted their request and told Samuel to appoint them a king (1 Samuel 8:19, 22). 

2. Meet King Saul: A Strong Start 

Saul was chosen to be Israel's very first king. The prophet Samuel anointed him, pouring oil on his head as a sign of God's calling (1 Samuel 10:1). God even gave Saul a powerful promise through Samuel: "Then the Spirit of the LORD will come upon you mightily... and be changed into another man" (1 Samuel 10:6). 

And for a time, Saul was a successful king. The Bible tells us he "fought against all his enemies on every side" and "acted valiantly," delivering Israel from those who plundered them (1 Samuel 14:47-48). He had a strong start, empowered by God to lead and protect the people. God didn't just give Saul a title; He gave him His Spirit, His power, and early victories. Saul was given everything he needed to succeed as a king who followed God. 

3. Saul's Disobedience: A Tale of Two Big Mistakes 

Despite his strong beginning, Saul's story is remembered for two major acts of disobedience where he chose his own judgment over God's clear instructions. 

Mistake #1: The Impatient Sacrifice 

The massive Philistine army had gathered to attack, and the people of Israel were terrified and "trembling" (1 Samuel 13:7). Saul was at a place called Gilgal, and he had been given a clear instruction: wait seven days for the prophet Samuel to arrive and offer a sacrifice to God for help (1 Samuel 13:8). 

But as the days passed and Samuel didn't arrive, Saul saw his soldiers scattering in fear. He became impatient and decided to take matters into his own hands. He offered the sacrifice himself, directly disobeying the command to wait (1 Samuel 13:9, 11). Just as he finished, Samuel arrived and told him he had "acted foolishly." The consequence was devastating: because he had not kept the Lord's command, he had lost a kingdom that God "would have established...forever" (1 Samuel 13:13-14). 

* Key Lesson: Use this story to show your kids how fear and impatience can lead us to stop trusting God's timing and His plan. Saul let what he could see—a scattering army—become more important than what God had said. 

Mistake #2: "Almost" Obedient is Still Disobedient 

Later, God gave Saul another very clear command through Samuel. He was to attack the Amalekites and "utterly destroy all that" they had. God was specific: spare nothing and no one—man, woman, child, or animal (1 Samuel 15:3). 

Saul and his army went and defeated the Amalekites, but they didn't follow the instructions completely. They spared King Agag and kept "the best of the sheep, the oxen, the fatlings, the lambs, and all that was good" (1 Samuel 15:9). When Samuel confronted him, Saul made an excuse, claiming the people spared the best animals "to sacrifice to the LORD your God" (1 Samuel 15:15). 

* Key Lesson: This is a powerful illustration of "partial obedience." Help your children see that Saul tried to justify his disobedience with a religious-sounding reason. He did most of what God asked, but he decided his own idea was better than God's clear command. 

4. The Heart of the Matter: "To Obey Is Better Than Sacrifice" 

This is the moment the whole story hinges on. Samuel's response to Saul's excuse is one of the most important verses in the Old Testament. He asked: 

"Has the LORD as much delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices As in obeying the voice of the LORD? Behold, to obey is better than sacrifice..." (1 Samuel 15:22). 

In simple terms, God cares more about our hearts trusting and obeying Him than He does about any big, impressive things we might try to do for Him. Saul thought a big sacrifice would please God, but God just wanted his simple, complete obedience. 

Because of Saul's repeated disobedience, the consequences were severe: 

* The Lord rejected him from being king over Israel (1 Samuel 15:26).  * The kingdom was torn from him and promised to another ruler, "a man after God's own heart" (1 Samuel 13:14, 15:28).  * The Spirit of the Lord departed from Saul (1 Samuel 16:14). 

5. The Good News: God's Unstoppable Plan 

It's easy to read this story and feel discouraged. But even in Saul's failure, we see God's incredible power to work all things for His good purpose. 

God turned the Israelites' sinful desire for a human king toward His ultimate plan. Saul's failure as king led to the rise of King David. It was to David that God made a promise of a kingdom that would "endure... forever" (2 Samuel 7:16). 

This promise pointed directly to Jesus, the ultimate King from David's line. He is the Word of God who "became flesh, and dwelt among us" (John 1:14), fulfilling the need for a perfect King. This pattern of God turning human failure into divine victory is woven throughout Scripture. We see it when Joseph's brothers sold him into slavery, an act God used to save their entire family (Genesis 50:20), and we see it most clearly at the cross. Even the worst act ever committed—the crucifixion of Jesus—was part of God's "predetermined plan" (Acts 2:23) to save His people from their sins and give them His righteousness (2 Corinthians 5:21). Man's failure never stops God's perfect plan. 

6. Bringing the Lesson Home: Activities for Your Family 

Discussing Saul's story can be a powerful way to teach your kids about the heart of obedience. Here are a few ideas to get started. 

* Conversation Starters:    

Play a game of "Simon Says" or create a listening-focused scavenger hunt where your kids have to follow a series of multi-step directions exactly. Afterward, talk about how much easier it is when we listen carefully to every word. 

  -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 

 A Heart That Obeys 

The story of King Saul is a powerful warning that God desires our obedience far more than our grand gestures. He is looking for a heart that loves and trusts Him enough to follow His commands completely. 

While Saul's story is a sober reminder of the consequences of disobedience, it also points us to God's incredible grace. His plan was never defeated by human failure. Instead, it led to Jesus—our perfect King who obeyed the Father perfectly, even to death on a cross. Through Him, we are forgiven for our disobedience and given new hearts that desire to follow Him.